Towering Columns
For The Times, Juliet Samuel raises the case for Habibi UK and why the state seems uninterested in investigating extremism.
The truth is that Habibi UK, real name Ben Tait, has been doing work our government should be doing, without any of the resources or protection. Having worked for the US state department for two years in his twenties, he later went into finance but, bored after the 2008 crash, took up blogging as a hobby while working as an energy consultant. In more recent years, his counterextremism skills attracted private backing and began to take up more time.
The volume and content of his work raises deeply uncomfortable questions: why are preachers in mosques from London to Liverpool allowed to call for the destruction of the Jews and the police do nothing? Why do radical pro-Palestine groups get away with harassing Jews at community centres and in neighbourhoods? What is the true world view of these people and how many of them are local officials and councillors, police officers, doctors and teachers? How do our institutions facilitate them?
What else is going on in mosques, in council meetings, in informal networks, that we should know about? How are they linked to international political Islamist movements? What is the role of the hard left in funding and organising for this movement?
In UnHerd, Dominic Adler argues that there is no reason for the government not to publish the full statistics on crimes committed by foreign nationals.
I served in the Metropolitan Police’s central intelligence unit for three years. I left the Service shortly before the 2020s “Boriswave”, but have a working knowledge of foreign offending ratios. I, along with most police officers and intelligence staff, know full well that the answers to these questions broadly reflect what the average person might imagine: that different cultural groups, living under different socioeconomic conditions, are more likely to commit certain types of crime. Could such data be misused by those with an agenda? Yes, fairly easily. Does that mean the data should be withheld? Certainly not. After all, in a mature democracy, shouldn’t public debate be informed by the available evidence?
There are certainly difficulties in publishing such information. Police data is often incomplete, while nationality data is occasionally reliant on an offender’s say-so. Then there are statistical anomalies concerning crime recording. For example, the MoJ figures turn on the number of people convicted of a crime, rather than those charged or found not guilty. Those figures could be even more alarming for the Government.
Nonetheless, why shouldn’t the figures that are available be released, along with suitable caveats around accuracy? The excuse of cost is clearly a red herring. Police IT systems are notoriously inefficient, but any competent police analyst is capable of providing eye-wateringly detailed performance figures around any conceivable type of crime. I remember that when a swathe of cashpoint robberies were committed by Slovakian criminals, the network was forensically dissected by colleagues from a regional organised crime unit. In many such cases, the material has already been collated.
For The Critic, Fred de Fossard shows how the ECHR is preventing the press from carrying out its job to inform the public.
David Walliams is not the first celebrity who has tried to use the courts to prevent stories being written about his behaviour and he will not be the last. What makes his case of interest is the way he went about it. Much ink has been spilled over the years writing about SLAPPs — Strategic Litigation Against Public Participation — whereby the rich and powerful pay the most expensive lawyers in the land to find ways of preventing embarrassing stories being published about their affairs. Methods vary. They can include making claims of defamation, harassment, the illegal use of data, or other allegations to delay or deny publication of stories.
This practice has been derided for many years by bodies like Index on Censorship and Liberty, as many of the people on the sharp end of a SLAPP have been investigative journalists or whistleblowers. Famous footballers stick in the mind, but we should remember how, in 2011, Andrew Marr caved on a super-injunction he had put in place in 2008 after an extra-marital affair (with another journalist), having haemorrhaged tens of thousands of pounds in the process.
What makes the Walliams case so interesting is his reliance on human rights law. He sought an injunction to ban the publication of the allegations under Articles 2, 3 and 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). These are rights often invoked by individuals against states, but in this case he claimed the people violating his human rights were not governments but journalists at ITN and The Guardian.
In The Telegraph, Tony Sewell says that we must not cut off white working class boys from a traditional curriculum.
Too many Neet young people are not struggling because they did too much Shakespeare or Latin. They are struggling because they never developed the confidence to take charge of themselves and the world around them.
The best training for that is the early development of the mind through ritual, rites of passage, and rules grounded in hierarchy – not career lessons or “life skills” modules.
Milburn is right that this is a moral crisis. But the answer is not to make our schools less academic. It is to protect the core knowledge subjects and make sure every child, not just those at Eton, leaves school believing that knowledge is theirs – and that they are confident enough to take the microphone.
For UnHerd, Tom Ough writes about the increasing public concern about the threat of AI and the lack of information about the risks it poses.
The public knows, therefore, that some risk is posed to it — and, rightly or wrongly, is no longer as trusting of apparent experts as it might have been in the past. Covid-19 is a recent reminder not only of societal fragility, but of the fallibility of our leaders. As for AI, the public’s mistrust is, once again, understandable: this is a technology that, in the view of its creators, would automate almost every human job if things go well. A recent poll found that only 9% of Americans believe AI does more good than harm, an astonishingly low number.
In the meantime, there could be additional danger. Though this month’s outages have caused irritation rather than catastrophe, they are an unfortunate demonstration of Western brittleness. As David Kennedy, a former NSA hacker, said on Tuesday: “When there’s smoke, there’s fire, and adversaries know this. So if our infrastructure is going down because it’s so fragile, they’re going to go right after that infrastructure.” We can only guess at what problems China, which is less forthcoming than the West about cybersecurity, might be encountering.
This time seven years ago, when Covid-19 was a couple of weeks away from being detected, prepping was considered eccentric. Should a few more outages befall the West, it will be considered eccentric not to prep. But there is no turning back; the AIs cannot be eradicated from humanity’s inventory. Our only option is to become comfortable in an internet in which we are not the only inhabitants — but one in which institutions and individuals alike are under constant threat.
Wonky Thinking
In new research, Capped Potential, Onward has found that that degree-level apprenticeships are now providing higher earnings than traditional degrees. Worryingly, the government is not investing in this route down despite its success and funding that could be helping young people to get the skills they need for well paid jobs is being diverted into other areas. In the week of the Milburn Review into record youth unemployment, we should be doubling on what works.
Degree-level apprenticeships combine a full degree with paid work and carry no tuition fee for the apprentice. Introduced in 2015, they have grown from 770 starts a year to just over 60,000, around one apprenticeship start in six, and they train nurses, clinicians, engineers, data scientists, accountants and town planners.
The evidence on outcomes is strong. On the Department for Education’s own earnings data, Level 6 apprentices who completed in 2022/23 had median earnings of £34,610 a year later, against £26,000 for first-degree graduates. Lower completion rates than traditional degrees are the most common criticism of the route, but they are widely misread: in the government’s 2023 evaluation, 94% of non-completers at Levels 6 and 7 were in work immediately after leaving, and the most common reason for leaving, cited by 24%, was a better job offer.
That success is now being rationed. The Growth and Skills Levy is forecast to raise £4.6 billion in 2026/27, yet the apprenticeships budget for England is £3.3 billion, leaving a significant gap even after funding for the devolved nations is accounted for. The Institute for Fiscal Studies estimates that levy receipts exceeded the apprenticeships budget by almost £840 million in 2024/25. As degree-level provision has taken a growing share of that budget, the Government has responded by restricting it. Since January 2026, public funding for Level 7 apprenticeships has been withdrawn for most people aged 22 or over, and in March 2026 it was announced that funding would be withdrawn from 16 further standards. Taken together, the two decisions remove funding support from roughly one in five apprenticeships begun in 2024/25.
This pressure is framed as rebalancing money towards younger people and lower levels, at a time of acute concern about the number of young people not in education, employment or training. This report accepts the urgency of that problem, but argues that the choice is a false one. Cutting the most successful earn-and-learn route only manages scarcity. The better course is to build a system that uses the levy for its stated purpose, keeps the confidence of employers and draws in more of their investment.
Podcast of the Week
Shadow Justice Secretary, Nick Timothy, appeared on the BBC’s Political Thinking to talk about his work investigating Islamism and his experience in politics. Timothy argues that we must fight back against an ideology that is infiltrating local government and other critical national institutions.
=========================================================================








